It becomes clear to the detectives that the four men have conspired to come up with a false account of what took place the night Hayley disappeared. Jake is assigned to track down Tim Finch's ex-wife to hear her version of events - and uncovers disturbing information about Chris Lowe's past. On a personal front, Sunny is offered the opportunity to rekindle his past marriage, and Cassie worries about her father's failing memory.

ヘイリーの失踪当日に教会で起こった盗難事件で、教会に残された窃盗犯の血痕とピートのDNAが一致。キャシーとサニーに呼び出されたピートは、教会へ盗みに入ったことは認めるが、ヘイリー殺害への関与は否定する。

세라의 막내아들 유세프가 세라의 과거 얘기를 엿듣고 단짝 친구에게 말한다. 세라가 매춘부였다는 소문이 삽시간에 마을에 퍼지고 세라는 무너지고 만다.

Cassie i Sunny wiedzą, że przyjaciele składają fałszywe zeznania. Sprawa komplikuje się, gdy prasa dowiaduje się o przesłuchaniu Jamesa.