The Pirates opening game is today, and everyone except Timmy is going. Timmy wishes he was at the game, but when Wanda lets Poof make the wish, they end up on a real Pirate ship. The wands get stolen, they get trapped in a net, and almost get attacked by crocodiles. When Timmy opens his big mouth, the pirate ship becomes land-born. The pirates attack the Pirates games, and the Pirates baseball team helps defeat them.

Timmy desidera andare a vedere la parata dei Pirati, la squadra di baseball di Dimmsdale, ma per sbaglio Poof porta a Dimmsdale una vera barca dei pirati, che iniziano a saccheggiare la città.

Timmy quiere ver jugar en vivo a sus jugadores de béisbol favoritos, "Los Piratas", sin embargo, sus padres sólo pueden conseguir dos boletos. Decidiendo cambiar de estrategia, Timmy desea ver a los Piratas en acción. Pero Cosmo y Wanda dejan que Poof conceda el deseo para que gane experiencia y los transporta accidentalmente al pasado, a los tiempos en que habían piratas reales.