Mike Sweeney has moved his family to Durham County after his partner was killed. His new neighbor, Ray Prager, who is his old nemesis from high school. Sadie is trying to fit in at school, while wanting to be like her father and dealing with the illness of her mother. Ray Jr. wants to be something that his father doesn't approve of.

A recent murder hits Mike hard. Sadie has to prove herself to get in with the cool kids. Ray is going crazy since his wife Traci has left him.

Mike Sweeney finds it more and more difficult to hide a painful secret. Ray Prager crosses paths with a serial killer and another woman dies.

Evidence mounts against Ray Prager and Detective Sweeney brings him in for questioning. Before long it's Sweeney who's under suspicion as Prager weaves a net of suspicion around his old rival.

Ray Prager gets close to Audrey Sweeney so he can manipulate Mike Sweeney's family. Mike and Audrey reach a boiling point while she staunchly defends Ray.