While in town to discuss a major deal with the Chicago Cubs, star ball player Andy Miller escapes serious harm when Gary saves him from being severely injured in a freak accident. Andy does bruise his shoulder during the incident, however, and Gary takes him to the hospital where Andy winds up falling in love with his physician, Dr. Suzy Pietro. Andy decides to accept the Cubs lucrative offer so he can stay in Chicago and be with Suzy. Unfortunately, Andy's agent doesn't want him to sign with the team and he soon learns that Suzy is contemplating a marriage proposal from another man. When Gary reads that Andy is going to choose a different ball club, he rushes to keep Andy with the Cubs and reunite him with Suzy.

Ignorant qu'il s'est fait avoir par une blague de Saint-Valentin, Gary court à l'hôpital pour la transplantation d'un coeur. Comprenant qu'il s'agit d'un moyen déguisé pour le chirurgien Steven Burroughs de demander en mariage le Dr Suzy Pietro, Gary se rend ensuite sur un terrain de base-ball afin de prévenir un accident qui pourrait paralyser l'un des meilleurs joueurs, Andy Miller. Il le ramène à l'hôpital et ce dernier tombe amoureux de Suzy...