Journalist David Farrier stumbles upon a mysterious tickling competition online. As he delves deeper he comes up against fierce resistance, but that doesn’t stop him getting to the bottom of a story stranger than fiction.

Featuring new, previously unseen footage documenting the bizarre and unsettling things that happened to filmmakers David Farrier and Dylan Reeve as Tickled premiered at film festivals and theaters in 2016. Lawsuits, private investigators, disrupted screenings and surprise appearances are just part of what they encounter along the way. Amidst new threats, the duo begins to answer questions that remained once the credits rolled on Tickled, including whether the disturbing behavior they uncovered will ever come to an end.

Marsha is simultaneously fascinated and furious when her first date with office manager Mike turns into a session in bondage and tickling. He ties her up with a rope and tickles her until she can barely stand it anymore. Marsha tells her co-worker Debbie about it, and Debbie tries to wrangle a date of her own with Mike. All goes according to plan until Marsha finds out about Debbie and invites her over for a little tickling payback of her own.

Village maidens beware! Dr. Ticklestein and his bizarre associate Igore are at it again. This time they've constructed the monster, Frankentickle, to assist them in their dirty deeds. One by one, the most beautiful girls in the village are taken, stripped, bound, and tickled senseless. All this horror is done in the futile quest for the elusive "T" spot.