Duncan's friends replace him with Kimberly in their online video game tournament, so he joins the opposition to betray them and humiliate Kimberly. Annie tries to force Jack to throw out all his old memorabilia that is cluttering the garage.

Annie gets her own public access court show after a confrontation with a rich resident who forced the Harrises from their favorite swimming spot.

Duncan says the one thing no kid should ever say to their dad, which shifts their power dynamic and forces Jack to confront his own father. Meanwhile, Kimberly and Jing have a window to do whatever they want, as Annie and Jack deal with Duncan's issue.

Jack and Annie hijack a middle school party thrown by the cool kids, to which Kimberly wasn’t invited. They then devise a plan to get the kids to their house, so Kimberly can “up” her popularity game, but things get out of hand. Meanwhile, Duncan and his friends work on creating a viral video, so they can become the next internet sensations.

Jack coaches Jing's little league soccer team, but when he feels he's too easy on the kids he calls on Duncan to yell at the team to get them to win. Meanwhile, Annie takes Kimberly to work with her after she has a falling out with her friends.

At the annual Witch Day Festival, Kimberly mixes up a magic witch potion that actually works, causing Jing to become possessed. Duncan and his friends enter a haunted Circuit City and Jack tries again to finally win Annie a stuffed animal at the milk bottle toss.