In December 1994, a house fire in small town Horn Lake, Mississippi claims the life of Lula Young, a beloved woman with terminal cancer; local law enforcement suspects foul play. Investigators’ hunt for the arsonist leads them to a suspect close to home whose greed knows no bounds, even murder.

After discovering a mother dead of an apparent suicide in 2017 in Corning, NY, police find evidence she was murdered. As detectives search for answers, they uncover a web of emotional manipulation that resulted in a deadly ultimatum and an unthinkable choice.